Who Has What It Takes to Lead the New York Jets to Success?
As the New York Jets search for their next head coach and general manager, fans are ready to see who will guide the team after a tough 2024 season. Robert Saleh was fired as the New York Jets' head coach on October 8, 2024, after the team started the season 2-3, following criticism of their performance and failure to meet expectations despite a talented roster. Jets are one of several NFL teams navigating the coaching pool. Over 10 candidates are reportedly in the mix, and the decision will be pivotal for the team's future. A key question is whether the Jets will hire a general manager before selecting a head coach. Aligning the two roles is crucial for a consistent vision and long-term success. With some candidates still involved in the NFL playoffs, the Jets may need to take their time to make the right choice.
Tier 1: Priority Hires
Joe Brady, the Buffalo Bills’ offensive coordinator, stands out as a top candidate. He is known for his offensive creativity and ability to develop quarterbacks, he could bring the spark the Jets need on offense. With speculation around the future of Aaron Rodgers and the Jets' quarterback situation, Brady’s proven track record in maximizing quarterback potential makes him an especially appealing option for a team desperate to rebuild its offensive identity. His innovative approach and experience building high-scoring units align perfectly with the Jets’ need for stability and explosiveness.
Tier 2: Strong Hires
Aaron Glenn, the Detroit Lions’ defensive coordinator, is a strong contender. He is a respected leader with a solid track record on defense, though he would need to pair with a skilled offensive coordinator to create balance. Josh McCown, currently the quarterback coach for the Minnesota Vikings, is gaining attention in coaching circles and could offer a fresh perspective and long-term potential. His background as a former NFL quarterback gives him an understanding of player dynamics that could translate into effective leadership.
Tier 3: Average Hires
Candidates like Steve Spagnuolo, the Kansas City Chiefs’ defensive coordinator, and Brian Flores, the defensive coordinator coach for the Vikings, have head coaching experience but mixed results. While Flores needs to address questions about his leadership style, the Jets are seeking more than just a defensive strategist, as they need a strong leader capable of guiding the team to consistent success. Spagnuolo, who has previous head coaching experience with the Rams, finished with a 10-38 record over three seasons. Jeff Ulbrich, who served as the Jets' interim head coach in 2024, is another name in this tier. While he stepped up during a challenging season, he doesn’t seem to be the best fit for the long term. Recently, the Atlanta Falcons interviewed Ulbrich for their defensive coordinator opening, which may be where his expertise is best utilized.
Tier 4: Last Resort
Some options come with more concerns. Matt Nagy, the Kansas City Chiefs’ offensive coordinator, and Ron Rivera, recently let go as head coach of the Washington Commanders, bring significant drawbacks. Nagy’s past struggles as a head coach for the Chicago Bears and Rivera’s recent lack of success make them less appealing. Rex Ryan, who served as the Jets’ head coach from 2009 to 2014, is a nostalgic option but not a practical one. Mike Vrabel was the first candidate taken off the board in New York, but not by choice. The New England Patriots quickly hired the Patriots Hall of Famer as their new head coach after their 4-13 season ended.
If the Jets want to rebuild their franchise, Joe Brady appears to be the best choice. His offensive expertise aligns with the team’s need for quarterback development and scoring. Alternatively, Aaron Glenn could be a strong option for his defensive leadership, provided he assembles a well-rounded staff. The Jets’ 2025 season depends on this critical decision. Whether they choose Brady’s offensive vision or Glenn’s defensive stability, this hire will shape the team’s direction for years to come. Fans will be watching closely, hoping this choice finally leads to sustained success and ends their playoff drought after 14 seasons.
